Have you read Miracles by CS Lewis. The first 3rd-ish is devoted to defining nature as a closed system of cause and effect and supernature as anything that intrudes on that system. Then he moves on to demonstrating supernature's necessity for human experience. It's what I think about when I consider this discussion of agi. AGI would be by design a closed system and not capable of those things that are central to the human inner life.
Have you read Miracles by CS Lewis. The first 3rd-ish is devoted to defining nature as a closed system of cause and effect and supernature as anything that intrudes on that system. Then he moves on to demonstrating supernature's necessity for human experience. It's what I think about when I consider this discussion of agi. AGI would be by design a closed system and not capable of those things that are central to the human inner life.
I have not, but I have heard of it now that you mention. Seems like the more academic counterpart to Chesterton's Orthodoxy.